Appeal loss for mortgage fraudster

Mortgage Rates

The scheme involved a series of transactions between 2007 and 2010 which deceived lending institutions into approving mortgage applications that contained false information and supporting documents.

Devoy, who was considered the ringleader of the group involved, was found guilty of 17 charges in relation to the scheme in June last year.

She was sentenced to five years jail with a minimum period of imprisonment of two years and six months.

While Devoy appealed her conviction and sentence to the Court of Appeal on the grounds that her trial lawyers made errors, three judges have now overturned her appeal.

Court of Appeal Justices Rhys Harrison, Murray Gilbert and Sarah Katz said the evidence of Devoy’s guilt was overwhelming.

"She has no rational basis for continuing to deny criminal liability," they said in their decision.

The Court of Appeal judges said both Devoy’s lawyers discharged their obligations with skill and care in demanding circumstances, while the judge had considered the evidence in meticulous detail.

"Devoy was the beneficiary of a very fair and competent judicial evaluation of charges to which she had no credible defence," they said.

"She cannot possibly claim that justice has miscarried in her case.”

In the original trial, Judge Brooke Gibson said there was a high level of "pure deceit and dishonesty" in Devoy’s offending.

She also told Devoy there was a complete absence of remorse on her part and that her protestations of innocence verged on fantasy.

Read more:

Mortgage fraudster heading to prison 

Keen for the best rate and some cash too?

We've teamed up with award winning mortgage experts, Squirrel.

With over 1,425 five star reviews on Shopper Approved, Squirrel has helped thousands of Kiwis just like you secure the best possible rate when refixing or refinancing. Squirrel often beats the advertised rates so it's worth getting them to review your mortgage.

shopper approved logofive star revews
R

Ryan

New Zealand

five star revews

The service I got from Squirrel was extremely efficient. They dealt with my loan so easily and achieved a result greater than what I was expecting.

J

Jo

New Zealand

five star revews

Highly recommend Squirrel to sort out a mortgage with the banks takes the hassle out of going to separate banks with so much information they do the hard yards for you - Baz was a superstar and helped me all the way to my new home.

Get a free mortgage review

All fields are required